Text logo reading 'Montauk Jacobs Well' with 'Montauk' in large white font and 'Jacobs Well' in smaller blue font underneath.

good company,
heartfelt service,
and unhurried moments

There is a rhythm to this place;
unhurried, familiar, and quietly assured.

Overlooking Calypso Bay Marina in Jacobs Well, Montauk Tavern is more than a destination; it's a place you'll find yourself returning to.

A return to the kind of hospitality that does not demand attention but earns it gently, moment by moment. Whether you arrive by foot or by water, you'll find your table waiting.

book a table
Boats docked at a marina during sunset with calm water reflecting the vessels and a rope fence in the foreground
Person squeezing lemon over fresh oysters at an outdoor dining table with a glass of white wine in the background.
The entrance to Montauk Tavern with a blue door, surrounded by lush green bushes and trees, including palm trees, and a pathway leading up to the door.
A plate of roasted chicken with gravy, mashed potatoes, and green peas on a white table outdoors. In the background, there is a glass of red wine, a white chair, and a grassy lawn with trees casting shadows.
Scenic view of a marina at sunset with sailboats docked, a wooden pier, bushes in the foreground, a calm water body, and a pastel sky.
People dining outdoors under umbrellas with live music performance by two musicians, one playing guitar, near a body of water with trees in the background.
A waitress serving food to customers in a busy restaurant with many people dining and drinking.
An outdoor dining area filled with people under umbrellas, surrounded by trees including palm trees and other large trees with thick branches, with a building with a gray roof in the background.
People relaxing and taking photos near a large tree by a body of water on a sunny day, with some seated in chairs and others standing and walking in the background.
Outdoor patio with picnic tables, blue umbrellas, palm trees, and a white gazebo under a partly cloudy sky.
Person holding a glass of beer under a tap with beer pouring into it at a bar.
A marina filled with numerous white boats and yachts docked in a calm body of water, surrounded by lush green trees and a residential area with white buildings, under a clear blue sky.
A bottle of Patrón tequila with a black straw, set on a white outdoor table alongside various dishes, with a blurred background of green trees and sunlight.

the kind of meal
you return for


There’s something quietly comforting
about a meal that feels familiar,
uncomplicated, generous, and thoughtfully made.

At Montauk, every meal is an invitation to slow down. It’s the warmth of something you’ve always known, served with just enough grace to make it feel truly special.

book a table
Two people clinking glasses of white wine and rosé wine outdoors during a meal at a wooden table with various dishes, including oysters, bread, a hot dog, and a dessert, with trees and water visible in the background.

a place to gather


Whether you're joining us for lunch, sunset drinks, dinner with friends or a special celebration, every visit is shaped by the water, the company around your table and the simple pleasure of staying a little longer.

book a table
Outdoor dining scene with food and drinks on a table, overlooking a river with trees and a large shade tree in the background.
A person holding a hamburger with lettuce, tomato, pickles, and cheese, sitting at a restaurant table with plates of fried food and French fries.
People walking and sitting in a warmly lit restaurant with wooden decor and large windows.
Plate of fried calamari, French fries, and a small cup of tartar sauce on a wooden table.
Aerial view of a marina with boats docked along a curved pier, surrounded by green lawns, palm trees, and buildings, with a large body of water in the background.
A busy restaurant interior with people sitting at tables, enjoying meals and conversation. Large glass doors open to a view of trees and outdoor umbrellas.
Close-up of a bowl of fried chicken tenders garnished with herbs, on a gray wooden surface outdoors with a blurred background of trees and sky.
Indoor restaurant or cafe filled with people sitting at tables, talking and dining. Warm lighting from woven pendant lights hanging from a dark wooden ceiling, large window in the background letting in natural light.
Close-up of espresso shot pouring from espresso machine into a white cup on a metallic drip tray.
A woman with long dark hair, wearing a black shirt, is serving food on a plate to a woman with glasses, long blonde hair, and a beige top at a busy restaurant or cafe. There are people sitting at a wooden table.
A top-down view of a wooden table with various dishes including oysters on a platter, a lobster roll with potato chips, a bread bowl with dip, a salad with tomatoes and mozzarella, and a plate with sliced baguette and cherry tomatoes with mozzarella,
Three drinks on a bar counter with a blurred outdoor background. One appears to be beer, another a mixed drink, and the third a dark cocktail.

set by the water. shaped by moments.

Some evenings come with a little more music, a little more gathering, a little more reason to stay.

From long lunches and live music to celebrations by the water, Montauk hosts moments that feel easy to join and hard to forget.

Nothing loud, nothing forced, simply moments, unfolding.

email events
A floral arrangement with white and light pink roses, green foliage, and other greenery attached to a wooden post outdoors on a sunny day.